Weights or cardio for weight loss?
Weights or cardio for weight loss? What the WHO, the ACSM and the STRRIDE AT/RT study show, and why the best answer is combining both with your diet.
Topic: Fat lossBy Fytform TeamUpdated on 7 min read

Article topics
- Why is this question so common?
- How much physical activity does the WHO recommend?
- What did the STRRIDE AT/RT study compare?
- What does the ACSM position stand say?
- So does diet matter most?
- How do you build a week that combines both?
- How does Fytform organize this in your plan?
- Sources
- Frequently asked questions
For weight loss, the best approach is to combine both: your diet creates the calorie deficit, cardio increases how much you burn, and weight training helps you keep and build lean mass. In the STRRIDE AT/RT study, aerobic training reduced weight and fat more, while weight training increased lean mass more. The WHO recommends 150 to 300 minutes of moderate aerobic activity a week and strength training on 2 or more days.
Why is this question so common?
Because each side has an argument that sounds good. Cardio fans point out that it burns more energy per session. Weight training fans say muscle "burns more" and makes your body look firmer. Both arguments are partly true, and that is exactly why the question "which one" leads to an incomplete answer.
The point that usually gets left out is that losing weight depends, first of all, on eating less energy than you burn over the weeks. Exercise contributes, but rarely on its own. If you want to understand the math behind it, the post calorie deficit: what it is and how to calculate yours walks you through it step by step.
How much physical activity does the WHO recommend?
The 2020 World Health Organization guidelines for adults aged 18 to 64 have two parts, and both apply at the same time:
- Aerobic: at least 150 to 300 minutes a week of moderate intensity, or 75 to 150 minutes of vigorous intensity, or an equivalent combination.
- Strength: muscle-strengthening activities at moderate or greater intensity, involving all major muscle groups, on 2 or more days a week.
In other words, the official health recommendation does not make you choose. It asks for cardio and weight training. The same guideline stresses that any amount of activity is better than none, which is a good reminder if you are starting from zero: begin with what fits into your week and build up gradually.
What did the STRRIDE AT/RT study compare?
One of the most cited studies in this debate is STRRIDE AT/RT, by Willis and colleagues, published in 2012 in the Journal of Applied Physiology. It included 119 sedentary adults with overweight or obesity, randomly assigned to one of three 8-month programs: aerobic only, weight training only, or both combined.
STRRIDE AT/RT results (Willis et al., 2012)
| Group | Weight and fat | Lean mass |
|---|---|---|
| Aerobic only | Reduced more than weight training only | Increased less |
| Weight training only | Reduced less | Increased more than aerobic only |
| Aerobic + weight training | Reduced more than weight training only (no difference vs. aerobic only) | Increased more than aerobic only |
The authors concluded that aerobic training was the most efficient mode for reducing weight and fat, and that a program including weight training is needed to increase lean mass. The combined group needed twice the training time and did not lose more fat than the aerobic-only group, but it was the only one that got both effects: less fat and more lean mass.
What does the ACSM position stand say?
The American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) published a position stand on physical activity for weight loss in 2009. A few points help set expectations:
- Between 150 and 250 minutes a week of moderate activity helps prevent weight gain, but on its own produces only modest weight loss.
- Physical activity improves weight loss in studies with moderate dietary restriction, but not in those that used severe restriction.
- Strength training did not increase weight loss itself, but it can increase fat-free mass and fat loss, as well as reduce health risks.
- Aerobic or strength exercise improves health markers even when weight does not change.
So does diet matter most?
For the number on the scale, yes. The ACSM itself shows that physical activity alone, in usual amounts, produces modest results. That is why the eating plan is the foundation of the deficit.
Exercise has other jobs that diet can't do: it increases daily energy expenditure, improves cardiovascular and metabolic health markers and, in the case of weight training, signals to the body that lean mass needs to stay. Combined with enough protein (see how much protein to eat a day), that stimulus is what separates losing fat from just getting lighter.
How do you build a week that combines both?
There is no single right split. What matters is covering both parts of the WHO recommendation in a way you can repeat. Some examples:
Sample weeks (adjust to your time and level)
| Days available | Weight training | Moderate cardio |
|---|---|---|
| 3 days | 3 full-body workouts | Brisk walks on the other days, adding up to 150 min or more |
| 4 days | 4 upper/lower workouts | 30 min after each workout + 1 walk of 30 min |
| 5 days | 3 to 5 strength workouts | 3 sessions of 50 min |
If you don't know yet how many days you can keep up, read how many days a week to train. And if the gym doesn't fit into your routine, you can cover the strength part with a home workout with no equipment.
How does Fytform organize this in your plan?
In the Fytform form (17 questions, about 5 minutes), you tell us your goal, how many days you train and where you train. The fat-loss plan uses a target 20% below your estimated daily expenditure and 2.0 g of protein per kg, and strength training is split so each muscle is trained twice a week: full body with 2 or 3 days, upper and lower with 4 or 5, push, pull and legs with 6.
The workouts take into account your equipment, the time you have and injuries, and the interactive workout log has a rest timer. Outside Brazil it is a one-time card payment with lifetime access to the plan; where checkout is not open yet, you can join the waiting list.
Sources
- World Health Organization 2020 guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour — British Journal of Sports Medicine (Bull FC et al.), 2020
- WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour — World Health Organization, 2020
- Effects of aerobic and/or resistance training on body mass and fat mass in overweight or obese adults — Journal of Applied Physiology (Willis LH et al.), 2012
- American College of Sports Medicine Position Stand. Appropriate physical activity intervention strategies for weight loss and prevention of weight regain for adults — Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise (ACSM), 2009
Frequently asked questions
Can you lose weight with weight training alone?
Yes, as long as your diet creates a calorie deficit. In the STRRIDE AT/RT study, weight training alone reduced weight and fat less than aerobic training, but it increased lean mass the most.
Cardio before or after weights?
The sources in this article don't compare the order. In practice, many people lift first so they come to the strength exercises fresh, but the most important thing is to hit the weekly volume of both activities.
How many minutes of cardio a week?
The WHO recommends 150 to 300 minutes of moderate aerobic activity a week for adults, or 75 to 150 minutes of vigorous activity, plus strength training on 2 or more days.
Does weight training make you lose weight more slowly?
The scale may move less because weight training favors keeping and building lean mass. The ACSM notes that strength training can increase fat loss even without increasing total weight loss.
Fytform Team
Written and reviewed by the Fytform editorial team on November 17, 2026. This is general information: it does not replace an individual assessment by a doctor, dietitian or fitness professional. Spotted a mistake? Write to contato@fytform.com.